Introduction
Curious to see what guests who have stayed in Quality Hotel Cargills Dunedin think about it? Read what guests who booked through HolidayCity have said about Quality Hotel Cargills Dunedin. We also have reviews by visitors who have visited the hotel (not necessarily through HolidayCity).
 
Overall Ratings by 17 Reviewers is:  3.6 
 
Recommended: 12 Not Recommended: 2 Neutral: 3
 

Hotel Ratings (out of 5)
3.4  Facilities 3.8  Location
3.4  Ambience 3.6  Service
3.6  Value for Money    

Room Ratings (out of 5)
3.8  Bed 3.6  Room Size
4  Cleanliness 3.5  Amenities
 

1 to 17 Quality Hotel Cargills Dunedin Reviews
 

Recommendation:  by robert johnston
 
Suitable for: Business, Leisure

enjoyed the stay and staff very courteous.

 
Hotel
  Facilities 4
  Ambience 5
  Service 4
  Location 5
  Value for Money 5
 
Room
  Bed 5
  Cleanliness 5
  Room Size 5
  Amenities 4
   

Recommendation:  by Derek Frank Smedley
 

We would definately visit again and recommend to our friends.

 
Hotel
  Facilities 5
  Ambience 5
  Service 5
  Location 5
  Value for Money 5
 
Room
  Bed 5
  Cleanliness 5
  Room Size 5
  Amenities 5
   

Recommendation:  by Steven Reynolds
 

 
Hotel
  Facilities 4
  Ambience 3
  Service 4
  Location 4
  Value for Money 3
 
Room
  Bed 4
  Cleanliness 4
  Room Size 4
  Amenities 4
   

Recommendation:  by Ross Cameron
 

Room pretty small - o remote for TV but nice hotel. Hs wireless broadband - a real plus

 
Hotel
  Facilities 3
  Ambience 3
  Service 3
  Location 5
  Value for Money 4
 
Room
  Bed 4
  Cleanliness 4
  Room Size 2
  Amenities 4
   

Recommendation:  by STEPHEN HART
 

 
Hotel
  Facilities 4
  Ambience 4
  Service 4
  Location 4
  Value for Money 4
 
Room
  Bed 4
  Cleanliness 4
  Room Size 5
  Amenities 3
   

Recommendation:  by Charles Scola
 

was not forewarned that prepaid freephone cards would incurr a heavy surcharge

 
Hotel
  Facilities 3
  Ambience 3
  Service 3
  Location 5
  Value for Money 3
 
Room
  Bed 3
  Cleanliness 3
  Room Size 1
  Amenities 3
   

Recommendation:  by JOHN BOOCOCK
 

This was not a comfortable hotel - the bar area was dark and gloomy - the restaurant area functional with little ambience - the food was good. it was more like a glorified Motel VERY disappointing - it was dark and gloomy and very impersonal - from descriptions I had expected something much moe attractive- the outside Board announces it as being acommodation of exceptional quality or something like that. it was very mediocre and we were very disappointed.

 
Hotel
  Facilities 2
  Ambience 1
  Service 2
  Location 3
  Value for Money 2
 
Room
  Bed 1
  Cleanliness 3
  Room Size 1
  Amenities 1
   

Recommendation:  by Frank Maio
 

The ambience was fantastic due to the layout of the rooms with a central coutyard garden. Great location

 
Hotel
  Facilities 4
  Ambience 5
  Service 4
  Location 4
  Value for Money 4
 
Room
  Bed 4
  Cleanliness 4
  Room Size 4
  Amenities 4
   

Recommendation:  by stacey gander
 

 
Hotel
  Facilities 4
  Ambience 3
  Service 4
  Location 4
  Value for Money 4
 
Room
  Bed 4
  Cleanliness 5
  Room Size 4
  Amenities 4
   

Recommendation:  by stuart spencer
 

 
Hotel
  Facilities 3
  Ambience 2
  Service 2
  Location 3
  Value for Money 3
 
Room
  Bed 4
  Cleanliness 4
  Room Size 4
  Amenities 4
   

Recommendation:  by Ashby
 

 
Hotel
  Facilities 4
  Ambience 4
  Service 5
  Location 3
  Value for Money 5
 
Room
  Bed 4
  Cleanliness 5
  Room Size 4
  Amenities 4
   

Recommendation:  by Peter Gardner
 

Some lights not working

 
Hotel
  Facilities 4
  Ambience 3
  Service 4
  Location 3
  Value for Money 3
 
Room
  Bed 5
  Cleanliness 4
  Room Size 4
  Amenities 3
   

Recommendation:  by byrne
 

 
Hotel
  Facilities 2
  Ambience 3
  Service 4
  Location 4
  Value for Money 4
 
Room
  Bed 4
  Cleanliness 4
  Room Size 4
  Amenities 3
   

Recommendation:  by Ferguson
 

Very enjoyable restaurant and good service To provide Pay TV

 
Hotel
  Facilities 3
  Ambience 4
  Service 4
  Location 3
  Value for Money 4
 
Room
  Bed 4
  Cleanliness 4
  Room Size 4
  Amenities 3
   

Recommendation:  by Harris
 

We did arrive early before the room had been completely cleaning but drink bottles from the previous occupants were still in the room.

 
Hotel
  Facilities 3
  Ambience 4
  Service 4
  Location 4
  Value for Money 4
 
Room
  Bed 4
  Cleanliness 3
  Room Size 5
  Amenities 5
   

Recommendation:  by Hewit
 

Very noisy upstairs boardwalks to upstairs rooms Hotel room very shabby in need of a makeover. Locks poor, washing machine did not spin dry

 
Hotel
  Facilities 1
  Ambience 1
  Service 2
  Location 2
  Value for Money 1
 
Room
  Bed 1
  Cleanliness 2
  Room Size 2
  Amenities 1
   

Recommendation:  by Justin Campbell
 

 
Hotel
  Facilities 4
  Ambience 4
  Service 4
  Location 4
  Value for Money 4
 
Room
  Bed 5
  Cleanliness 5
  Room Size 4
  Amenities 4
   
 
 

Not what you're looking for?